Search This Blog

Showing posts with label justice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label justice. Show all posts

Thursday, July 10, 2025

Where is the Justice in Trump’s first Hundred Days, and former aide Musk’s too?

 When we look at the outpouring of events in the first hundred days of the administration, it is hard for progressives to see any impacts that even have a modicum of sense and justice. What we see is a slow rolling coup undertaken by Donald Trump with the endorsement of Republican Senators and members of Congress. These actions are violations of the Constitution and should be resisted by us all in every way we can. Let us look closely to see what exactly has been going on.


Legal and organizational analysts have identified several different aspects of justice. At one  level there are distributive (the result of the encounter with the justice system), retributional (the balance between crime and punishment) , and restorative justice (an attempt to rebuild the relationship between the wronged and the person doing the wronging). Within each of these, three types of justice or injustice can occur: the outcome (the final state can be fair or unfair), the procedure used to reach that outcome (individuals can have a say in how the outcome was reached or not have a say), and the interactions of the individual with the justice system (the person can be treated with respect or they can be bullied and disdained).


Let us see how the last 100 days have played out.


Early Days


In the early days of the administration, Elon Musk invited federal employees to accept a buyout. While this is not a good way of downsizing if you want to have an effective strategically driven process, it is what was offered. 


Was the outcome fair for the federal employees? Employees who took the offer were offered 34 weeks of severance pay. That seems like a reasonable deal for the average federal worker with 13.5 years of service and an age of 47.5 who under standard severance would receive 28 weeks pay. It would be a better deal for shorter tenure and young workers but a worse one for older, longer service workers.


Was procedural justice served in this case? It was:  people had a choice whether or not to accept the offer; though perhaps the threat of future involuntary lasy-offs influenced their decisions .

.


Was interactional justice served in this case? Yes: people in government were not being roundly abused at this stage.



A Bit Later


A few weeks into the administration, the DOGE gang started moving from department to department slashing and burning. How was justice Served?


Distributive Justice

Very unfair. People were not fired for cause (i.e. poor performance). However, they did receive the standard severance pay based on their tenure and age.



Procedural justice

There was none. People had no say in whether they were fired or not. It was a top down decision by the DOGE team; their own managers did not have any say in the matter and may well  have been fired also.


Interactional Justice

This was terrible. The firing letter said that they were being fired for poor performance. This was untrue for many people who had recently received stellar performance ratings from their bosses. The disdain was even worse for those “probationary” employees who had been promoted within the past two years (and hence being on probation in the new position). Furthermore, the whole civil service has been disparaged by Mr. Musk who has said that their jobs are not real jobs, that they don’t produce anything, and essentially are a waste of space.



Retributional Justice


 In his campaign Mr. Trump promised he will be our retribution and he has delivered with alarming efficiency. He has removed Secret Service protection from many who served him faithfully until they criticized him: e.g., Mike Pompeo, John Bolton. On the face of it this seems an unfair outcome, is clearly lacking in procedural justice, and is interactionally unjust.


Mr Trump has removed security privileges from many individuals including former President Biden. Here this is probably fair, as it is tit-for-tat for Biden doing the same for him. However it is procedurally unjust, and interactionally indefensible as Trump has called his predecessor “the worst President ever’ many times.


From his very first day, Mr Trump has ordered the resignation of government officials or for the Department of Justice to investigate them. Most of these are, on the face of it unfair, but one or two like targeting those who investigated Trump could be justified as tit-for-tat responses. Procedurally there were no negotiations, and the vituperation in Trump’s comments made them interactionally unjust.


The attacks on law firms, Universities, and other institutions are additional examples of retribution. They lack justice in all three domains: outcomes, procedure, and interaction.


Perhaps the worst examples of Trumpian injustice is his treatment of immigrants and of foreign students. Immigrants without any serious criminal record have been herded up and shipped to El Salvador in defiance of court orders – a serious breach of procedural justice. Students from abroad, practicing free speech –on topics that Trump decries – have been arrested and imprisoned. Again, the administration is fighting court orders about their treatment, a procedural violation. Judges have been arrested and threatened. 


Restorative Justice


There is no evidence that this administration practices, or even understands, restorative justice. On April 30th., Mr. Trump explicitly rejected restorative justice when he announced that he could bring back Kilmar Abrego Garcia from El Salvador but that he had no intention of doing so. I suppose Trump supporters would argue that pardoning the January 6th.  insurgents was a form or restorative justice. It was not, it was  a perversion of justice. It had no means of restoring the relationship between the victims and the perpetrators as were his other pardens of gang leaders and fraudsters.  It was harsh retributional justice where the judicial system got a poke in the eye and the villains got out of jail, and worse, did not have to pay reparations.




What next?


The Trump administration unlike most of its predecessors in practicing injustice in outcomes, procedures, and interpersonal attacks. The country is in turmoil. We have not seen the like before.


People ask what we can do My answer, very conventionally, is that we should protest every appalling act undertaken by this administration. We should protest every violation of procedural justice. We should protest every act of interactional injustice. Do not let any of this become “normal.” March. Phone your representative politicians, if they are Republicans ask why they are enabling Trump; if they are Republicans, ask staffers why they are still working in the office of someone who is enabling Trump. Write to the media. Write a blog or maintain a social media account. Keep on doing so. Above all, do not give up.



Monday, June 14, 2021

DOJ u-turn

 Letter in Boston Globe on DOJ

Sunday, May 18, 2014

The inconsistency of Chief Justice Roberts

Op Ed in MetroWest Daily News

It is no longer on the website.

Here is what I wrote:

 

There are many qualities that excellent justices require. First is what is called the judicial temperament; that is, according to the American Bar Association, “compassion, decisiveness, open-mindedness, sensitivity, courtesy, patience, freedom from bias and commitment to equal justice.” Second must be a thorough knowledge of the law. But neither of these are much use unless the judge shows consistency; consistency in outcomes for similar cases, consistency in the logic used to reach the outcome, and also consistency in what is and what is not allowed to influence the decision.

If these characteristics are desirable in a trial judge, how much more necessary they are in a Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. Yet Chief Justice Rogers has shown himself to be lacking in consistency with which he marshals the reasons for his decisions. We need to make a close comparison between the recently decided McCutcheon case (McCutcheon et al. versus Federal Election Commission, 2014) and an Arizona Case decided in 2011 (Arizona Free Enterprise Club’s PAC et al. versus Bennett, Secretary of State of Arizona, et al., 2011).

 In McCutcheon Roberts makes very clear that speculation of what might occur (such as the funneling of excessive funding to a candidate or party through a complex of committees) is irrelevant in deciding the issue. Only verifiable events that have actually occurred can be considered as evidence in this case. He writes:

 “And— importantly—we “have never accepted mere conjecture as adequate to carry a First Amendment burden.” Nixon v. Shrink Missouri Government PAC, 528 U. S. 377, 392 (2000).“

He is saying here that one must have a strong factually based argument in order to make a decision involving the freedom of speech. In fact such joint committees already exist and Washington lobbyists like Covington & Burling are celebrating:

“we expect today’s decision will increase the political power of Members of Congress who have a strong relationship with high net worth donors. We also expect it to increase the influence of major donors.”

However, in Arizona, he took a quite different tack. The Arizona law provided public financing to candidates whose opponents exceeded a threshold amount of private funding. At first glance, this would appear to fulfill the requirement that more speech (or money in Robert’s view) in an election is better.  However, Chief Justice Roberts speculated that the existence of the threshold would create a disincentive for privately financed candidates to raise and spend as much as they could because this would trigger an additional public financing for opponents. Thus the law inhibits, according to Roberts, the free speech of the privately financed candidates. Here speculation, based on very little evidence other than affidavits from political candidates stating that they believed that if public funding were available, they would have been unable to raise funds, is admitted as a fundamental rationale for the striking down of the Arizona law.

It would nice if Chief Justice Roberts were consistent in his rejection of speculation in both these cases. Just as it would have been nice if he had upheld the doctrine of “stare decisis” which he promised to do at his confirmation hearings.

Chief Justice Roberts is inconsistent. He is unreliable. The American people deserve better of the Chief Justice of the United States.


Wednesday, May 8, 2013

Justice at Guantanamo. When?

Mr. Carroll is one of many calling for the closure of Guantanamo where over 80 people cleared of terrorist activity languish still. Eighty innocent people in jail, this is unconscionable
However, he remains confined by the thinking that requires these people to be sent to "foreign countries willing to receive them."  ( It's your turn. Boston Globe, May 6, 2013). But there may not be any willing countries.

If we cannot release them into the est of the world, then they should be released into the United States. That, after all, is the full implication of Colin Powell's dictum: "If you broke it, you own it." We have broken these people's lives and are continuing to do so. It is time to stop and to provide some restitution.
Mr President, let these people go.
As for those who are awaiting trial, the President should defy Congress -- just as it defies the President -- and issue an executive order to bring them all to the United States for trial in our Courts, which are well capable of providing a fair trial.
Mr Obama should have done this on the first day of his Presidency, but better now than further delay.

Sent to Boston Globe

Monday, April 29, 2013

Over 80 people are being held in  Guantanamo after being cleared of any terrorist involvement. This is unconscionable.

Mr. President, Let These People Go.
If we cannot release them into their own countries, then they should be released into the United States. That, after all, is the full implication of Colin Powell's dictum: "If you broke it, you own it." We have broken these people and are continuing to do so. It is time to stop.
As for those who are awaiting trial, the President should defy Congress -- just as it defies the President -- and bring them all to the United States for trial in our Courts, which are well capable of providing a fair trial.
Mr Obama should have done this on the first day of his Presidency, but better now than further delay.

Wednesday, December 12, 2012

Money Laundering

It seems to me that there should be a difference between the way we treat Banks and the way we treat Bank Executives (HSBC to Pay $1.92 Billion to Settle Charges of Money Laundering. New York Times, December 10, 2012).

It may be that there were good reasons to not charge the Bank for criminal activity because it might cause the Bank to fail -- withdrawals by depositors, sell-off by shareholders.  I can not see a similar argument for not bringing criminal charges against the top executives of the company.

They were in charge. They were receiving top dollar for the oversight of the banks myriad activities. It is no defense that they were ignorant of what was going on. They should have known. The Buck Stops at the Top.

We cannot be indifferent to the drug related murders in Mexico and even on our own streets. Their money laundering facilitated the operation of the drug cartels. They should be charged.

Sent to New York Times

Thursday, March 29, 2012

Responses to Questions the Justices Asked about Obamacare

Memo to Justice Kennedy who asked: "Can you create commerce in order to regulate it?"

  • Interstate commerce exists when uninsured New Hampshire residents, living the State's motto "Live Free or Die," go to emergency rooms in Massachusetts hospitals.

Memo to Justice Scalia: who asked why people should have to pay for maternal care or pediatric care if they did not intend to use it?

  • Everyone in the courtroom received pediatric care; everyone in the courtroom's mother received maternal care. 
  • Our generation  has not been very good at ensuring inter-generational equity. We need to pay forward for the health care of the next generation.

Case closed!

Martin G. Evans
Nancy R. Evans

Sent to Boston Globe

Friday, June 3, 2011

States Secrets Blocks Resolution of Contractors' Case

The two recent decisions by the Supreme Court not to intervene in State Secrets cases means we have to seek a legislative solution (State Secrets Block Resolution of Contractors' Suit, Justices Say. New York Times, May 24, 2011: A17).

The States Secrets Protection Act was introduced by a bipartisan coalition into the last two Congresses following the 2007 report by the American Bar Association on the misuse of the States Secrets Privilege.

The bill should be re-introduced and passed in a timely fashion by both Houses of Congress. The bill will allow judicial review of whether or not the States Secrets defense is justified. Instead of having to rely on the word of the Government, there will be appropriate judicial review. Such review is essential when we remember that the initial acceptance of the States Secrets privilege was built on a lie in the original 1953 Reynolds decision.


Sent to New York Times

Friday, May 6, 2011

Legality 1, Reality 0

What kind of mindset inhabits the brains of the senior officials of the Justice Departments (Detainees' Lawyers Can't Click on Leaked Files. New York Times, April 27, 2011: A1, A10).

We have moved from the Orwellian world of George W. Bush where torture was given the euphemism, "enhanced interrogation" to the Kafkaesque world of Barrack Obama where unindicted suspects live in legal limbo at Guantanamo and Leavenworth.

President Obama, that is not the kind of change I voted for.

Sent to New York Times

Saturday, March 19, 2011

The Prison that Won't Go Away

President Obama has decided to keep open the military prison at Guantanamo and will continue trial by Military Commission (The Prison That Won't Go Away, New York Times, March 8, 2011).

After President Nixon ordered his Attorney General to fire Special Prosecutor Archibald Cox, Attorney General Elliott Richardson and his deputy William Ruckelhouse resigned in protest.

Where are resignations from the Justice Department in protest against this misguided policy?

Why has no one raised a voice against a policy that will continue to damage the US in terms of its standing abroad, especially in the Arab world.

Because it is President Obama, from whom so much was expected, who has endorsed the Bush policy, it may be that the world's reaction will be even more severe than it was to the intial imposition of the policy.

It is a sad day for America.


Sent to New York Times

Saturday, March 12, 2011

Obama's new Gitmo policy

If there is one thing that George Bush did that destroyed America's image in the world, it was the sequestering of terrorist suspects in the prison at Guantanamo bay – America's Devil's Island. For a time, it seemed that with the Obama Administration in power, there was a chance that America's reputation might be restored (Obama's new Gitmo policy is a lot like Bush's old policy, Washington Post, March 8, 2011).

Alas, President Obama has accepted the George W. Bush mindset and has decided that laws and natural justice are irrelevant and that we will continue to hold suspects at Guantanamo Bay; and that we will continue to deny them trials in American courts, courts that have shown a remarkable capacity for providing fair trials to terror suspects; and that we will continue to hold some suspects indefinitely without trial.

The country and the world expected better of Obama, so the damage to our reputation caused by his “acceptance of the political reality” and abandonment of American values will be all the more severe.


Sent to Washington Post

Tuesday, January 11, 2011

A response to the Citizen's United ruling

OpEd in the Providence Journal



This has vanished from their website, so here it is

A Citizen's response to the Citizens United Ruling

Martin G. Evans


The Supreme Court has, in its Citizens United decision, unleashed a flood of corporate and union money into the election process. In so doing, it has overturned a hundred years of precedent. It would appear that this has changed the face of elections for the future. We now have anonymous donations going to pay for advertisements supporting corporate and union agendas.

What can we do about it?

These are the issues on which citizens should focus their attention.

First we need to bring into alignment the tax treatment of individuals and corporations when it comes to political expenditures. If I give $500.00 dollars to my favorite candidate, this sum comes from my after tax income. The same should be true of corporations. Any money from their treasury expended on political activity should not be treated as a business expense so should come from their after tax income. Making this non -deductible will also enhance transparency as it will have to appear as a separate line in the Corporation's income statement. I would like to see similar treatment for their lobbying activity on Capitol Hill and in the Statehouses around the nation. The difficulty there is that some lobbying is likely to be a legitimate expense while other lobbying is purely political in nature; we may have to impose an arbitrary fraction of those expenses (say 30% as tax deductible while the rest comes out of after-tax income.

If allowing no deductions seems too harsh, we might adopt the system used in Canada. There, to encourage small donations to political parties, the first $400 of contribution receives a tax credit of 75%; that is one's tax bill is reduced by $300 if one gives $400.00. The next $350 receives a credit of 50%; the next $525 receives a credit of 33.33%. Donations over $1275 receive no tax benefit. These diminishing credits could be granted to both individuals and corporations to encourage broader participation in the financial support of politicians.

Second we need to bring the treatment of corporations and unions into alignment. Since the Supreme Court's decision in Beck v. Communication Workers of America (1988), Unions have had to rely on “voluntary” contribution from members to fund their political activities. In that case, the Supreme Court ruled that Unions could only legally collect fees to cover their administrative and collective bargaining expenses; thus members could opt out of paying any additional dues that were used for political activities. As opting out was a fairly difficult process, it is not clear how many union members took advantage of the reduced union dues available under the Beck ruling. Nevertheless, this does place a potential constraint on unions' political expenditures: if too much is spent in this way, more members may opt out thus reducing the unions’ ability to play in the political arena.

The equivalent constraint for a corporation would be for shareholders to have the right to control corporate political activity. Such constraints might be imposed in two ways. First the shareholders as a body might be required to vote on the next year’s political activity budget and on broad lines on the issues on which it is to be expended. Given the lethargic shareholder governance that currently exists, this would leave the decisions on political expenditure where it is today: in the hands of top management. The second approach would be to give each shareholder the right to “opt out” of making a contribution to political activity. He or she could request that her/his proportion of the political budget be redirected to charity instead of being used for political activity. Alternatively, the individual shareholder could direct to which politician(s) his or her share of the political budget was to be directed. Equitable treatment of Unions and Corporations requires that one or other of these systems to constrain corporate spending be incorporated as quickly as possible.

On the legislative front, we need to pass the DISCLOSE bill that would insist that corporations and unions be open and above board in acknowledging their corporate expenditures. In the Citizens United decision, the Supreme Court called for but did not mandate full disclosure. Just as individual contributions have to be fully disclosed, then as persons, corporate disclosure should also be mandated. One alternative route for disclosure might be for the SEC to issue a regulation that all corporations listed on US stock exchanges had to show in the quarterly and annual reports to the SEC a line item showing the corporation's political expenditures in the previous period. Another alternative might be for states (including Delaware) to insist that providing such a line item would be a condition of incorporation in the state.

Finally, transparency would permit consumer pressure to be brought on corporations. Just as, in the recent campaign (2010), Target was excoriated by many consumers and progressive groups for its support of a gubernatorial candidate in Minnesota who opposed same-sex marriage. It might also be feasible to start a campaign whereby consumers asked that their portion of cash-flow contributions that went to political activity be redirected to charity. Such consumer control is a long way off.

We need to work at both the state and federal levels to pass legislation that will expand shareholder and consumer rights in the domain of corporate political expenditures. Then democracy will be returned to the people.


He is Professor Emeritus of Organizational Behavior at the Rotman School of Management at the University of Toronto.

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

Bureaucratic Failure in the case of Shirley Sherrod

The indecent haste with which the Department of Agriculture engineered Ms. Sherrod's
resignation suggests a major failure in the bureaucratic protections that the Federal
Government has in place for its employees.

To be fired without any attempt to hear her side of the story, without a full
consideration of all the facts suggests gross incompetence in senior management of the
agency.

They should be disciplined.
--

Friday, July 2, 2010

Supreme Court and Maher Arar

I share your outrage that the Supreme Court has refused to take on the case of Mr Maher Arar (New York Times, June 15, 2010), a Canadian who was wrongly accused of terrorist links, and who was arrested in New York, rendered to Syria where he was tortured, before returned to Canada.

This refusal was, in part, based on arguments by the Justice Department that "the court should not investigate the communications between the United States and other countries because it might damage diplomatic relations and affect national security."

It is difficult to see what further harm could be done. The case was extensively studied by a Canadian Royal Commission and Mr. Arar was cleared of wrongdoing and given a large financial settlement. The trouble is that the refusal to open this case is based upon the docrine of "the States Secrets Privilege." This allows the State to be its own judge in deciding what is or is not a State Secret. The privilege was born of a lie in the 1950's and should not be allowed to continue in its present form.

The Justice Department in this case and others is continuing to follow the policies of the Bush Administration. It should not. Rather it should give strong support to The States Secret Protection Act of 2009[H.R. 984/ S417] which will allow for checks and balances in the use of the privilege. This law still languishes somewhere on the Congressional Calendar.

We should note that in this case, the Supreme Court has followed the doctrine of stare decisis; quite a contrast to its overturning one hundred years of precedent for campaign financing.


Sent to New York Times

Sunday, April 25, 2010

Paedophile Crisis

A deeply dysfunctional organization is one that does not learn from its mistakes.
In 1993, Cardinal Bernard Law of Boston, breaking the 7th commandment, called down the wrath of God on the Boston media for outing a paedophile priest in Fall River, MA.
Today, the Vatican excoriates the New York Imes for its coverage of stories that bring the shame of near involvement in a new coverup to the Pope.
The Vatican is simply and sadly repeating a losing course of action.


Sent to New York Times

Thursday, March 4, 2010

Report Faults 2 Who Wrote Terror Memos

Shame on your headline writer (Report Faults 2 Who Wrote Terror Memos, New York Times, February 20, 2010: A1, A9). They were Torture Memos not Terror Memos.

Shame on the Justice Department for arguing that the context of the times justified sloppy legal arguments. It is when we are under attack that we should hew most strongly to our ideals.

Sent to New York Times



A Hand in a House of Cards

The legal efforts to punish the rating agencies are insufficient (A Hand in a House of Cards, New York Times, February 16, 2009. We need to do something so that going forward the agencies' conflicts of interest are reduced.

Let the agencies' paymasters be the investors. Each financial transaction would have a small fee attached to it, like a Tobin tax. These fees would be used to pay the rating agencies; to keep them honest, a portion of the pay would be tied to achievement, that is the medium and long term accuracy of their ratings.

Such a system would eliminate the current conflict of interest faced by the rating agencies who are paid by the very firms/issuers they rate.

It is a great shame that Congress has not yet moved to correct this situation.

Sent to the New York Times

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

No sanctions for authors of torture memos

Your article on the decision not to prosecute John Yoo said that the statute of limitations had expired for his reprehensible conduct (No sanctions for authors of torture memos, Boston Globe, February 1, 2010).

I cannot believe that there is any statute of limitations for a person who advocated war crimes (torture).


Sent to Boston Globe


Thursday, February 4, 2010

How to Keep Scott Brown OFF Balance

I was wondering how to keep Scott Brown off balance for the next three years. Here are the results of my Monday morning fantasy all based on his advocacy of water-boarding to extract information from terror suspects.


1. Surely he cannot be allowed to take the Senate oath to uphold the constitution when he is on record as advocating actions that surely contravene the 8th amendment on cruel and unusual punishment.

2. For his statements on water-boarding, the US attorney for Massachusetts should bring a prosecution for advocating criminal activity. Water-boarding is contrary to the Geneva Convention and US anti-torture laws.[it would be sweet if Martha Coakley could have been prosecuting officer, but I think it is a federal crime that I suspect him of.]

3. The Massachusetts bar should initiate proceedings to disbar lawyer Brown for his advocacy of criminal activity.

4. As a Lt-Colonel in the National Guard, Brown is subject to military discipline. The Judge Advocate General should bring Court-Martial proceedings against Brown for advocating interrogation techniques that are well outside the military's guidelines.

I think the best chance is #4. #1 is untested and I doubt the Senate would want to create a precedent. If federal prosecutors (#2) [also this is probably protected under the first amendment as he is not advocating actions that would put someone in immediate danger] and bar associations (#3) have taken no action against the developers of the torture memomrandums, then there is little chance of disbarring Brown. However many have been Court-Martialed for engaging in torture and some have been Court-Martialed for permitting it on their watch, so that might have a small chance of success.

OK. Back to Monday morning reality. Brown will take his seat today.