Search This Blog

Showing posts with label trump. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trump. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Basic Research

 It is incredibly worrying that the Trump administration is planning to screen basic research proposals for consistency with the administration's priorities (Science Agency Diverts Money Meant to Fund Basic Research. New York Times, October 4, 2026: A19).


Thanks to economists like Edwin Mansfield, we have known for over 40 years that unfettered, unguided, unconstrained basic research has contributed measurably to our economic prosperity.

The administration's approach is misguided. We need to build a strong, high wall between political ideologies and basic scientific research. Having political commissars deciding scientific research priorities will be very dangerous. Political commissars, like Secretary Kennedy, America's Lysenko, will kill the seed corn, basic rresearch, that keeps America great.

The Kennedy Center, Washington DC

 Mr. Trump is not known for respecting legal niceties. I think The Times is very optimistic if it believes that Mr. Trump will give 30-days notice before moving on the Kennedy Center (Can Trump Legally Raze the Kennedy Center? New York Times, Oct. 2nd:C4).


The only thing that will save the Center is collective citizen action. We must demonstrate our disapproval physically. We need a 24/7 ring of individuals surrounding the Kennedy Center. The ring-makers must prevent Trump and his minions (police, ICE agents, demolition workers) from getting within wrecking ball distance of the Kennedy Center.

We must stand up against Trump's voracious appetite for destruction.

Monday, November 17, 2025

Trump, Tariffs, and the Supreme Court

 


I hope that the Supreme Court decides quickly in the case of Mr. Trump’s claim to be able to make unilateral decisions on the imposition and removal of tariffs (Highlights of the Supreme Court Argument of Trump's Tariffs, New York Times, November 5th, 2025) . I hope that it will deny hm that right.

America, its businesses, and its supply chains cannot long survive Mr. Trump’s volatile, uninformed, unpredictable, and arbitrary decisions.

Even a temporary stay, signed by a majority of the whole Court, would be useful.


Sent to New York Times

Thursday, July 10, 2025

Where is the Justice in Trump’s first Hundred Days, and former aide Musk’s too?

 When we look at the outpouring of events in the first hundred days of the administration, it is hard for progressives to see any impacts that even have a modicum of sense and justice. What we see is a slow rolling coup undertaken by Donald Trump with the endorsement of Republican Senators and members of Congress. These actions are violations of the Constitution and should be resisted by us all in every way we can. Let us look closely to see what exactly has been going on.


Legal and organizational analysts have identified several different aspects of justice. At one  level there are distributive (the result of the encounter with the justice system), retributional (the balance between crime and punishment) , and restorative justice (an attempt to rebuild the relationship between the wronged and the person doing the wronging). Within each of these, three types of justice or injustice can occur: the outcome (the final state can be fair or unfair), the procedure used to reach that outcome (individuals can have a say in how the outcome was reached or not have a say), and the interactions of the individual with the justice system (the person can be treated with respect or they can be bullied and disdained).


Let us see how the last 100 days have played out.


Early Days


In the early days of the administration, Elon Musk invited federal employees to accept a buyout. While this is not a good way of downsizing if you want to have an effective strategically driven process, it is what was offered. 


Was the outcome fair for the federal employees? Employees who took the offer were offered 34 weeks of severance pay. That seems like a reasonable deal for the average federal worker with 13.5 years of service and an age of 47.5 who under standard severance would receive 28 weeks pay. It would be a better deal for shorter tenure and young workers but a worse one for older, longer service workers.


Was procedural justice served in this case? It was:  people had a choice whether or not to accept the offer; though perhaps the threat of future involuntary lasy-offs influenced their decisions .

.


Was interactional justice served in this case? Yes: people in government were not being roundly abused at this stage.



A Bit Later


A few weeks into the administration, the DOGE gang started moving from department to department slashing and burning. How was justice Served?


Distributive Justice

Very unfair. People were not fired for cause (i.e. poor performance). However, they did receive the standard severance pay based on their tenure and age.



Procedural justice

There was none. People had no say in whether they were fired or not. It was a top down decision by the DOGE team; their own managers did not have any say in the matter and may well  have been fired also.


Interactional Justice

This was terrible. The firing letter said that they were being fired for poor performance. This was untrue for many people who had recently received stellar performance ratings from their bosses. The disdain was even worse for those “probationary” employees who had been promoted within the past two years (and hence being on probation in the new position). Furthermore, the whole civil service has been disparaged by Mr. Musk who has said that their jobs are not real jobs, that they don’t produce anything, and essentially are a waste of space.



Retributional Justice


 In his campaign Mr. Trump promised he will be our retribution and he has delivered with alarming efficiency. He has removed Secret Service protection from many who served him faithfully until they criticized him: e.g., Mike Pompeo, John Bolton. On the face of it this seems an unfair outcome, is clearly lacking in procedural justice, and is interactionally unjust.


Mr Trump has removed security privileges from many individuals including former President Biden. Here this is probably fair, as it is tit-for-tat for Biden doing the same for him. However it is procedurally unjust, and interactionally indefensible as Trump has called his predecessor “the worst President ever’ many times.


From his very first day, Mr Trump has ordered the resignation of government officials or for the Department of Justice to investigate them. Most of these are, on the face of it unfair, but one or two like targeting those who investigated Trump could be justified as tit-for-tat responses. Procedurally there were no negotiations, and the vituperation in Trump’s comments made them interactionally unjust.


The attacks on law firms, Universities, and other institutions are additional examples of retribution. They lack justice in all three domains: outcomes, procedure, and interaction.


Perhaps the worst examples of Trumpian injustice is his treatment of immigrants and of foreign students. Immigrants without any serious criminal record have been herded up and shipped to El Salvador in defiance of court orders – a serious breach of procedural justice. Students from abroad, practicing free speech –on topics that Trump decries – have been arrested and imprisoned. Again, the administration is fighting court orders about their treatment, a procedural violation. Judges have been arrested and threatened. 


Restorative Justice


There is no evidence that this administration practices, or even understands, restorative justice. On April 30th., Mr. Trump explicitly rejected restorative justice when he announced that he could bring back Kilmar Abrego Garcia from El Salvador but that he had no intention of doing so. I suppose Trump supporters would argue that pardoning the January 6th.  insurgents was a form or restorative justice. It was not, it was  a perversion of justice. It had no means of restoring the relationship between the victims and the perpetrators as were his other pardens of gang leaders and fraudsters.  It was harsh retributional justice where the judicial system got a poke in the eye and the villains got out of jail, and worse, did not have to pay reparations.




What next?


The Trump administration unlike most of its predecessors in practicing injustice in outcomes, procedures, and interpersonal attacks. The country is in turmoil. We have not seen the like before.


People ask what we can do My answer, very conventionally, is that we should protest every appalling act undertaken by this administration. We should protest every violation of procedural justice. We should protest every act of interactional injustice. Do not let any of this become “normal.” March. Phone your representative politicians, if they are Republicans ask why they are enabling Trump; if they are Republicans, ask staffers why they are still working in the office of someone who is enabling Trump. Write to the media. Write a blog or maintain a social media account. Keep on doing so. Above all, do not give up.



Saturday, February 1, 2025

Strategy for blocking Trump

 It is time for the Democrats to adopt devious tactics in the Senate and the House of Represetatives.


There are enough upright Republicans willing to vote secretly against Trump’s nominees and plans. However, they are not willing to take a public stand against him because they fear retribution through being primaried by a Trumpish MAGA opponent.

Democrats should make deals with these Republicans that, if they vote against Trump, the Democrats will not put up a Democratic candidate at the next General Election. In this case, even if primaried, the current incumbent could run as an Independent and pick up the centrist and moderate left voter and might even get Democratic support and votes.

Democrats and centrist Republicans could push for a change in the rules of the House and Senate so as to require that nominees and bills be voted on with secret ballots. This would reduce the fears of centrist Republican senators and Representatives that they might be primaried. I realize that this is a longshot given the leakiness of their offices.

Finally, we, the public, must continue what we are doing, especially in red states and districts, contact our senators, contact our representative and insist that they grow spines and vote to block or undo Trump’s most outrageous actions.

America’s survival depends upon it. 

Monday, January 27, 2025

 Senator Graham believes it was wrong for President Trump to pardon the January 6th rioters. I agree.


In that case, why on earth did he vote for Mr. Trump's nominee for Secretary of Defense, the unqualified Secretary Hegseth?

Doesn't he know that the "tit for tat" strategy (i.e., a vote against the nominee) is the best way to stop someone from doing the nation harm?

Maybe next time.

Sunday, December 8, 2024

Dr. Bhattacharya, Covid, Sweden, and the Future

 The nomination of Dr. Jay Bhattacharya to head up NIH reminds me that there was one country, Sweden, that tried to follow the principles outlined in the Great Barrington Declaration. That is, it tried to protect the elderly while allowing most other people to carry out their day to day activities unimpeded.


How did that work out? I think the results were mixed. Early in the pandemic, 2020, Sweden had over 1½ times the number of excess deaths(that is, deaths from all causes, including Covid) proportionate to the population than did other Scandinavia countries (Denmark, Finland, and Norway).  This is to be expected, as few measures were taken in Sweden to reduce the incidence of the disease in the general population.


However in 2022 with the introduction of vaccination, Sweden’s excess death rate was about ½ the rate in the remaining Scandinavian countries. Sweden reduced its excess death rate while the rate in the other Scandinavian countries increased. This is what the Great Barrington Declaration predicted: that lock-downs and other restrictions at the front end of the epidemic would result in additional excess deaths when the epidemic was over. It is too early to judge whether this long tail will continue.


 Finally, Covid deaths in Sweden, as opposed to excess deaths from all causes, over the whole course of the epidemic from 2020 to November 2024 showed Sweden doing badly: over 1½  times as many Covid deaths, proportionate to the population, as in the other Scandinavian countries.


We should note that Scandinavia as a whole, including Sweden, did better than many other European countries and much, much better than the USA where Covid death rates were higher than those in Scandinavia (leaving out Sweden). At the height of the pandemic, states controlled by Republicans had higher excess death rates than those controlled by Democrats.


As the threat of a new pandemic (a bird flu crossover to humans) approaches, we need to decide carefully which restriction over our behavior are necessary and which can be ignored. We must follow the data painfully gained from the recent Covid pandemic.


Appeared in Cambridge Day, Jan 2025

Friday, November 1, 2024

Sunday, April 30, 2023

Ukraine War

 We now know the two likely candidates in the presidential election (Biden Declares 2024 Bid; Possible Rematch in Sight, New York Times, April 26, 2023: A1, A12).

We also know very clearly where Mr. Biden stands in defense of Ukraine.

Mr. Trump and his associates have had dealings with both Kyiv and Moscow.

Mr. Trump needs to state clearly his position going forward with the Ukraine war.

Sunday, April 16, 2023

Trump and Biden's Secret Documents

 I think we are down to two counts against Mr. Trump now: January 6th and Georgia.

At least in the court of public opinion, there can do longer be any case for Mr. Trump’s handling of secret documents.

 The current leaks are doing real damage to Ukraine.

It just shows that justice must be applied swiftly otherwise reality gets in the way.


Sent to New York Times

Monday, September 5, 2022

Trump and the 60-day rule

 Justice delayed is justice denied. It is past time for justice to be done for the majority of Americans despite the 60-day "rule" (Unwritten Rule Poses Dilemma for 2 Inquiries. New York Times, September 5, 2022: A1, A10).

In a couple of months between the election and the January 6, 2021, meeting to certify the election, Mr. Trump and his allies managed to file (and lose) 59 cases alleging election fraud and win one case. They attempted to suborn election officials in multiple states. They managed to harvest over 150 votes in congress to decertify the electoral votes of several states. That is quite an achievement in a short amount of time.

In contrast, America has shown great deference to the former president. The January 6th Congressional Committee Has presented evidence that would provide the basis for charges to be laid against the President. No charges have yet been laid. The FBI has uncovered evidence that the former president has mishandled government documents and that he or his associates have obstructed an FBI investigation. As yet, no charges have been laid.

Mr. Trump is devious and has a reputation for "lawyering up". He must be brought to justice now. He should be arrested as soon as possible and denied bail.

Mr. Trump has always acted as though rules are for other people; he should not be protected by the 60-day rule.

Submitted to the New York Times.

Monday, June 14, 2021

DOJ u-turn

 Letter in Boston Globe on DOJ

Thursday, July 23, 2020

Lessons from Mueller


Lessons from the Mueller Report
(Report On The Investigation Into Russian Interference In The 2016 Presidential Election)
 

With the dropping of charges against General Flynn and with the Supreme Court’s hearing about the partial release of Grand Jury testimony gathered by Special Prosecutor, Robert Mueller, and with the recent opening of senate investigations, we are re-focusing on the Mueller investigation. There are some lessons for us still to learn from his report.

I will look in detail at several elements:
1.      Mueller’s failure to file charges for Finance Law violations (conspiracy with the Russians) arising from the June 9th 2016 meeting between Trump campaign representatives and Russian operatives
2.      The obfuscation and contortions so evident in his discussion of why the President was not indicted on obstruction of justice charges.

No Charges for violations of the Campaign Finance Laws.
From his report, it is clear that he bent over backwards not to indict two members of the President’s family (Donald Jr. and Jared Kushner) and the then manager of his presidential campaign, Mr. Manafort. As is well known, the three confidants of Mr. Trump, responded positively to an invitation from a Russian lawyer to receive some dirt on Hilary Clinton. Mr. Trump Jr. is quoted by Mueller as saying: “if it’s [sensitive high level information] what you say I love it especially later in the summer.”
Mueller levies no charges because he thought he would have difficulty providing proof of a crime because of the question of whether there was anything of value being offered to the campaign and whether the participants in the meeting knew that they were breaking the law. Anything of value would have to be reported as a donation to the campaign and donations from foreigners are explicitly forbidden.
Mueller’s discussion of value [Chapter 5.B.3.a, b. i, iii) concludes like a brief provided by a defense attorney rather than a statement of the grounds for or against prosecution. He does begin by describing the kind of information that would be valuable: law enforcement reports, classified materials, confidential information on a competitive bid, grand jury information, and relevant here, “in the public corruption context … the value the defendant subjectively attaches to the items received.” In addition, the Federal Elections Commission has stated that value also resides in political membership lists, mailing lists, state-by-state lists of activists, polling data, and campaign materials. The law also specifies that value resides in what the participants expect to receive before the meeting took place.  However, Mueller dismissed all of this claiming that there was no way to establish the value of what was offered to the Trump team. This despite the fact that before the meeting, the Trump’s team was told and believed that the information would incriminate Hillary Clinton and that it would be helpful to Donald Trump’s campaign.  Mueller’s second reason for rejecting the idea that there had been a violation of the Election Law based on the value of a gift was the fact that “no judicial decision has treated the voluntary provision of uncompensated opposition research or similar information as a thing of value that could amount to a contribution under campaign finance law.” The argument that compensation is required for the contribution to be a violation of the law seems bizarre.
Finally, he argues that he could not lay charges because the Trump representatives might not have known that they were breaking the law in receiving something of value from the Russians. Although ignorance of the law is usually not a defense, with campaign finance law, the potential wrongdoer must do so “knowingly and willfully.” Mueller thought that Trump’s team might be able to activate this defense so decided not to charge them. I would have thought that Manafort being both a lawyer and being the campaign manager should have been aware of the law and would have been worth charging.

Obfuscation on Obstruction of Justice
The saddest statement in the report comes in the introduction to the section on Obstruction of Justice. It reads: “Accordingly, while this report does not conclude that the President committed a crime, it also does not exonerate him.”
There is one reason and one reason only why Mr. Mueller did not draw the conclusion the President was a criminal: Justice Department rulings and memoranda that a sitting president could not be indicted. Recently several judges have questioned the applicability of these memoranda because they “do not constitute authoritative judicial interpretation of the Constitution concerning those issues.” Note that Mueller was concerned about the lack of such a ruling in the case of uncompensated gifts to a campaign; this weighed in his decision not to bring charges.
Mueller identified ten events that gave prima facie evidence that Mr. Trump, as President, obstructed justice. These include pressure on the FBI to go easy on General Flynn, through the firing of FBI Director James. Comey, through the attempts to hide the purpose and outcomes of the July 9th. Meeting.
All clearly qualify as obstruction of justice.

Implications
From the whole report, we need to take Mr. Mueller’s warning seriously and erect cyber defenses against Russian interference. Both government, through election protection, and the private sector, through disabling bots, must do their parts.
Second, we must revise the election finance law so that it is harder for people to plead ignorance. At the very least, knowledge of the law should be assumed for the candidate, her or his family, the campaign manager, and the senior staff of the campaign.
Finally, the idea that the President cannot be indicted while in office needs intense scrutiny. Surely wrongdoing that increases the chance of a person becoming President should be indictable. Certainly the idea of Presidential immunity should be tested in the courts.

Wednesday, July 1, 2020

Failure to receive intelligence

We should not be at all surprised that  Mr. Trump's National Security Team was unwilling to pass up bad news (Susan Rice: TrumpPuts Russia First. New York Times, July 1, 2020: A25.

After all, back in April 2017, Generals Mattis and McMaster failed to tell Mr. Trump that he was wrong in his report of the direction in which a US aircraft carrier was proceeding (https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/18/world/asia/aircraft-carrier-north-korea-carl-vinson.html).

Most organizations face the problem of information distortion as it goes up the hierarchy. Good chief executives make sure that they have multiple channels of information so that they get a rounded view of the situation they are facing.