Search This Blog
Showing posts with label toronto. Show all posts
Showing posts with label toronto. Show all posts
Friday, June 10, 2011
Tuesday, May 24, 1988
Selling the University Library
So the University of Toronto would like to sell off its libraries; or at least lease them out for 15 years. What a way to try to raise money! The University should be a pillar of excellence and integrity; a symbol to the workaday world. Once the University scurries around in the pages of the Income Tax Act to find some obscure provision that, in collaboration with some cash-rich company it can exploit, the University is behaving little better than the worst of the research incentive flippers.
The University ha sunk to new depths in creating a loophole in the income tax law. And I think it is the creation of a loophole. My understanding of the tax act is that a deduction is allowed on depreciating assets to allow a company to purchase and write off productive assets that have a reasonable expectation of generating a profit. My personal library is a productive asset and can be written off against my consulting income. Some years I even make a profit. How is the University Library a productive asset for an oil company or an automobile manufacturer?
Where is the reasonable expectation of profit from this particular leasing activity? If it is not a productive asset, then the company has no moral right to write it off against productive income. The company may have the narrow legal right; but morally it is just engaging, with the University as accomplice, in something close to tax evasion.
The U of T should have no part in such a plan. The treasurer of Ontario is to be applauded for his stand on this issue.
There are also a host of practical implications concerning the control of the assets (the library). Are all employees of the company to be issued with library access cards? That at least would give some semblance that the asset was a productive one for the company. Would the company be entitled to direct what additions should be made to the library and what books were to be de-accessed; getting rid of muckraking company histories for example?
Then there is the knotty question of ultimate ownership. Can the sale and lease agreement be made so watertight that the University is the ultimate recipient of the library? what if the owning company is taken over; what if it needs to raise cash; what if it goes bankrupt! I think that in such situations, the assets might be under legal dispute for years and i an extreme case faculty and students banned from using them. Only lawyers could get rich from such events.
This whole episode underscore the North American disease: fine minds are spending time shuffling paper assets rather than getting on with the job of improving productive activity. Successive governments of course face some blame for the chronic underfunding that has lead to these creative machinations. But tax games are not the province of the University and certainly not of the provincial university. The University knows better; it should live by the spirit, not the letter, of the law.
The famous library at Alexandria had the privilege of being burned. Those of Ontario's universities are about to suffer a much worse fate: being privatized.
University of Toronto Bulletin
The University ha sunk to new depths in creating a loophole in the income tax law. And I think it is the creation of a loophole. My understanding of the tax act is that a deduction is allowed on depreciating assets to allow a company to purchase and write off productive assets that have a reasonable expectation of generating a profit. My personal library is a productive asset and can be written off against my consulting income. Some years I even make a profit. How is the University Library a productive asset for an oil company or an automobile manufacturer?
Where is the reasonable expectation of profit from this particular leasing activity? If it is not a productive asset, then the company has no moral right to write it off against productive income. The company may have the narrow legal right; but morally it is just engaging, with the University as accomplice, in something close to tax evasion.
The U of T should have no part in such a plan. The treasurer of Ontario is to be applauded for his stand on this issue.
There are also a host of practical implications concerning the control of the assets (the library). Are all employees of the company to be issued with library access cards? That at least would give some semblance that the asset was a productive one for the company. Would the company be entitled to direct what additions should be made to the library and what books were to be de-accessed; getting rid of muckraking company histories for example?
Then there is the knotty question of ultimate ownership. Can the sale and lease agreement be made so watertight that the University is the ultimate recipient of the library? what if the owning company is taken over; what if it needs to raise cash; what if it goes bankrupt! I think that in such situations, the assets might be under legal dispute for years and i an extreme case faculty and students banned from using them. Only lawyers could get rich from such events.
This whole episode underscore the North American disease: fine minds are spending time shuffling paper assets rather than getting on with the job of improving productive activity. Successive governments of course face some blame for the chronic underfunding that has lead to these creative machinations. But tax games are not the province of the University and certainly not of the provincial university. The University knows better; it should live by the spirit, not the letter, of the law.
The famous library at Alexandria had the privilege of being burned. Those of Ontario's universities are about to suffer a much worse fate: being privatized.
University of Toronto Bulletin
Thursday, August 1, 1974
Toronto: Architectural walk
ublished: Globe & Mail, Toronto.
A seven-block walk of architectural whims
by Griffith Evans
Originally illustrated with six photographs by Globe & Mail photographer Dennis Robinson.
I wonder whether anyone else has an interesting walk to the subway as I do? Do people even notice? I must admit that the weather in winter inhibits observation. Most of the points of interest are well above eye level, and the biting wind tends to keep eyes firmly focused on the sidewalk. On the seven blocks I walk, along Yonge Street from Briar Hill to Eglinton, the roving eye can find at least half a dozen features of the older buildings that are a delight. No doubt others have their own favorites.On the corner of St Clements Avenue stands the North Toronto YWCA. On the whole it is an unimpressive concrete building with large picture windows, usually filled with notices about activities for liberated mothers. However, if you let your eyes pass upward, the most amazing riot of art deco confronts you. Above each window is a large grey, metal panel about half as big as the window and covered with an intricate design of whorls and circles. As if this were not enough, High on the roof line, a magnificent eagle carries a two-sided clock – it is a solid squat bird with the faces of the clock rising up between its wings.
Farther down Yonge Street on the same side, the Capitol Cinema building stands on the corner of Castlefleld, here above the shop signs is a feature of some interest— fluted pilasters, venetian windows and some thin Adamesque designs. On the opposite side of Yonge, we find our next treasure -- and what a treasure, for me, it makes the whole walk worth it even on the coldest days. On the facade, up above the plastic and neon sign advertising Nino's pizza house, i s the full face -- stark white against the yellow-brown brick -- of a roaring lion. It is pleasingly framed In a line of white cornice.
Now back to the original side -- to Shaw's college, the one building that redeems this block. Shaw's has a plastered Spanish look, and you should notice in particular the rainpipes, and the boxes at the point that they disappear into the walls -- they are of a smart black against the creamy stucco of the building.
The next point of interest is the police station. The building itself is fairly dull -- grey stone with some Egyptian style ornament relieved with some yellow-grey brick. However, the light fixtures on the doors are worth a glance. I particularly liked the one on the door farthest north -- it has a delightful nineteen thirties touch.
Our next building for close examination is another gem of the nineteen thirties -- to be precise 1936 -- it must be one of the few buildings in the Commonwealth to display the insignia of King Edward VIII. This, of course, is the post office. In front of the main door stand two slim columns supporting stylized -- not my style I am afraid, I prefer that full blooded lion over Nino's -- Lion and Unicorn supporters of the Canadian and Quebec coats of arms. The real finds on this building are four small bas-reliefs high up on the building.
These represent four current modes of transportation -- on the front of the building, ship and rail; on the north side, a streamlined vehicle, a nd on the south side, best of all. a seaplane with fat squashy pontoons.
Farther on, the block from the post office down is gradually being engulfed with a rising vertical tide of development. On these new buildings, there are no bas-reliefs or odd decorations for tomorrow's walker to discover and enjoy.
Mr. Evans is a Toronto teacher.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)